Why EVs Are Polarizing

Feb 3rd, 2024 - Category: Change

We have all noticed how electric vehicles (EVs) have rapidly moved from a niche market to the forefront of global transportation discussions. Unfortunately this transition isn’t just a technological evolution; it’s deeply intertwined with political dynamics. I recently came across this video from the popular “State of Charge” YouTube channel and the bottom line seems to be that “social acceptance cuts both ways.

EV Opinions This chart comes from a national survey of 600 voters with income of $50K+. The source indicates that it is estimated to represent about a third of the 2020 electorate. So while it may seem a bit outdated by this point, more than a few of the 1,100 comments make it clear that the data is still valid even though the gap between ideologies is narrowing.

Here’s is a summary of several more key political aspects related to electric vehicles:

  1. Environmental Policy: EVs are often at the center of discussions about environmental policy. Governments keen on reducing carbon emissions see them as a critical tool in achieving climate goals. Policies like subsidies for EV purchases or investments in charging infrastructure are common ways governments promote EV adoption. Interestingly Wikipedia points out that “As of December 2023, China had the largest stock of highway legal plug-in passenger cars with 20.4 million units, almost half of the global fleet in use.”

  2. Economic Factors: The shift to electric vehicles also has significant economic implications. It affects industries from oil and gas to automotive manufacturing. Countries that rely heavily on oil exports may view the rise of EVs as a threat, while those with large automotive industries see it as an opportunity for economic growth and job creation. For example, Wyoming tried to pass a bill phasing out EVs by 2035, it did not pass but it was not surprising in the context of the fact that the state has been sustained by the fossil fuel industry for decades.

  3. Geopolitics of Battery Production: The geopolitics of EVs extends to the materials needed for their batteries, like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. These materials are not evenly distributed around the globe, leading to new dependencies and strategic considerations for countries vying for leadership in the EV market. This is a complex topic with a massive amount of complex, conflicting data.

  4. Regulatory Landscape: The regulatory environment for EVs varies significantly across the globe. Some countries have set ambitious targets for phasing out internal combustion engines, while others have more lax approaches. These regulations directly impact the pace of EV adoption and the strategies of automotive companies.

  5. Public Perception and Political Ideology: As discussed at the beginning of this article, public perception of EVs can be influenced by political ideology. In some regions, EVs are seen as a symbol of environmental responsibility and technological progress, while in others, they may be viewed as impractical or as a threat to traditional industries.

  6. Infrastructure Challenges: The politics of infrastructure is also crucial. Developing a widespread charging network is essential for EV adoption, and this often requires public-private partnerships. How and where this infrastructure is developed can be a contentious political issue, particularly in underserved areas. In New Mexico, we cannot drive from Santa Fe to Las Cruces in a non-Tesla EV without at least one potentially lengthy (overnight?) stop.

  7. International Collaboration and Competition: Lastly, the EV market is a field of both international collaboration and competition. Countries and companies are both cooperating in technological development and competing for market dominance. This dynamic affects trade policies, international relations, and technological innovation.

In conclusion, electric vehicles are much more than just a technological advancement; they are a nexus of environmental, economic, and geopolitical interests. Understanding the political landscape around EVs is essential for stakeholders ranging from policymakers and business leaders to consumers and environmental advocates.

Note: This article was written with support from ChatGPT.